John Locke on Personal Identity and Memory

Added:

The Circularity Objection and the Brave Officer Paradox

John Locke’s memory-based theory of personal identity faced immediate and enduring criticism from philosophers like Joseph Butler and Thomas Reid. Butler argued that Locke's theory is circular: memory cannot define personal identity because memory presupposes identity. To genuinely remember an action, one must have been the person who performed it; thus, identity must exist prior to memory. Reid illustrated a logical flaw in Locke's view with his famous 'Brave Officer' paradox. Suppose an old general remembers his deeds as a brave young officer, and the young officer remembers being flogged as a boy, but the general has forgotten the childhood flogging. According to Locke, the general is the officer, and the officer is the boy, yet the general is not the boy. This violates the logical law of transitivity (if A=B and B=C, then A=C). These critiques suggest that memory is merely evidence of personal identity, not its constituting factor, pointing instead toward theories of bodily continuity or substantial soul-based identity.

The basic concept of metaphysical identity and persistence (e.g., how an object remains the 'same' over time, illustrated by puzzles like the Ship of Theseus).
Descartes' rationalist view of the self as an immaterial substance (the soul), which Locke's psychological theory directly challenges.
Locke's empiricist epistemology, specifically the idea that knowledge and concepts arise from sensory experience rather than innate ideas.
The philosophical distinction between a 'man' (a biological organism) and a 'person' (a thinking, self-aware agent capable of moral responsibility).
Thomas Reid's 'Brave Officer Paradox' and Joseph Butler's circularity objection, which expose potential logical flaws in Locke's memory-based theory.
Derek Parfit's psychological continuity theory (Relation R) and the 'bundle theory' of the self, which modernize and revise Locke's views.
The 'Animalist' critique of psychological identity (e.g., Eric Olson), which argues that human beings are fundamentally biological organisms rather than psychological entities.
Practical applications of personal identity in bioethics and law, specifically regarding moral responsibility in cases of severe dementia, amnesia, or multiple personality disorders.
169.1K views1.6Klikes1:46@bbcradio4Original Release: 2015-01-19

John Locke proposed that personal identity is determined by memory rather than bodily continuity; he argued that memories connect the different parts of our lives, meaning that if two people switched memories, the person with the criminal's memories would be responsible for the crime regardless of their physical body, and that genuine forgetting of an action absolves one of responsibility because one cannot be held accountable for actions they cannot remember.