Knot Theory 1: Coloring, Equivalence, and the Trefoil Knot

Added:

Physical Knot Theory and Ropelength Constraints

While classical knot theory treats knots as abstract, infinitely thin, and infinitely stretchable topological loops, "Physical Knot Theory" introduces a critical alternative perspective by factoring in physical constraints such as thickness, stiffness, and friction. In this view, topological equivalence defined by Reidemeister moves is insufficient for understanding real-world knots, such as those found in DNA, polymers, or macromolecules. For example, two knots that are topologically equivalent may be physically distinct because transitioning between them requires passing through states that violate physical limits, such as minimum "ropelength" or maximum curvature. By focusing on the geometric energy of knots and tight configurations rather than pure topological deformation, physical knot theory provides a vital counterpoint that bridges abstract mathematics with empirical sciences.

Basic topology concepts, specifically the intuitive notion of continuous deformation and homeomorphisms.
Equivalence relations and equivalence classes, to understand how different projections represent the same underlying knot.
Basic modular arithmetic (especially arithmetic modulo 3), which is essential for understanding tricolorability calculations.
Fundamentals of graph theory and planar projections, to grasp how 3D knots are represented as 2D knot diagrams with crossings.
The construction of stronger algebraic invariants, such as the Alexander Polynomial and the Jones Polynomial.
Seifert surfaces and the concept of a knot's genus, which provides a geometric way to study knot properties.
The classification of knots, including prime versus composite knots, and how to read standard knot tables.
Physical and biological applications of knot theory, such as DNA replication, protein folding, and polymer entanglement.
37.2K views846likes50:51@MathatAndrewsOriginal Release: 2019-01-09

Knots can be distinguished using coloring invariants: a knot diagram is p-colorable (for prime p ≥ 3) if its arcs can be labeled with numbers 0 to p-1 such that at each crossing, the sum of the undercrossing labels equals twice the overcrossing label modulo p. By constructing a matrix from crossing equations and computing its determinant, we determine p-colorability—if p divides the determinant, the knot is p-colorable. This method, derived from Reidemeister's three fundamental moves, provides a powerful tool to distinguish knots, though it cannot distinguish all knots as some non-equivalent knots share the same determinant.