The Sublime in Thomas Aquinas: A Philosophical Exploration

Added:

The Kantian and Historical Critique of the 'Thomistic Sublime'

Opposing perspectives, particularly from Kantian and historical-critical scholars, argue that projecting the modern concept of the "sublime" onto Thomas Aquinas is anachronistic and philosophically incompatible. Classical Thomistic aesthetics are grounded in beauty (pulchritudo), which Aquinas defined through proportion (proportio), integrity (integritas), and clarity (claritas). These principles emphasize a harmonious, rational, and divinely ordered cosmos where everything is ultimately intelligible. In contrast, the post-Enlightenment sublime (as formulated by Immanuel Kant and Edmund Burke) is defined by formlessness, overwhelming vastness, terror, and the failure of human comprehension. Critics argue that Thomistic metaphysics cannot accommodate the genuine existential dread and cognitive limits of the sublime because Aquinas views nature not as an intimidating, chaotic force, but as a structured reflection of divine wisdom. Thus, trying to extract a theory of the sublime from Aquinas distorts both his theology of creation and the unique, subjective nature of modern aesthetic experience.

Immanuel Kant's aesthetic theory of the sublime, specifically the distinction between the mathematical and dynamical sublime.
The core tenets of Thomistic metaphysics, particularly Thomas Aquinas's concepts of existence (esse), essence, and the transcendentals (Truth, Goodness, and Beauty).
The historical development of the concept of 'the sublime' in aesthetics, originating from Longinus and Edmund Burke.
Thomistic epistemology, focusing on how human intellect abstracts spiritual or universal truths from physical, sensory experiences.
An exploration of modern Neo-Thomist aesthetics and its dialogue with contemporary art and literary theory.
A comparative study of theological vs. secular aesthetics, examining how post-modern thinkers like Jean-Luc Marion approach the concept of the 'saturated phenomenon'.
The application of a Thomistic sublime to environmental philosophy, assessing how it frames humanity's relationship with and stewardship of the natural world.
Advanced analysis of Aquinas's 'Five Ways' (Quinque Viae) through an aesthetic lens, exploring if the sublime can function as an experiential pathway to the divine.
119 views3likes55:30@ThomasAquinasCollegeOriginal Release: 2026-03-31

The sublime is best understood as 'arduous beauty'—beauties that because of their greatness are challenging and thus merit a spirited response; unlike Kant's view that the sublime is purely about human cognitive and moral superiority, this Thomistic account holds that the sublime is a mode of beauty that engages our spirited part (thumos) through the experience of difficulty in comprehending cosmic vastness and power, while still ultimately revealing the divine splendor that transcends complete human understanding.