Linear perspective, discovered by Filippo Brunelleschi around 600 years ago, is a mathematical technique that projects three-dimensional scenes onto two-dimensional surfaces by having parallel lines converge at vanishing points, enabling artists to create realistic spatial illusions; this principle is applied in modern contexts from film production to sports advertising, and different cultures developed alternative projection systems like axonometric projection for different artistic purposes.
The Mathematics of Perspective in Renaissance Art and Modern Applications with Sarah Hart
Added:so today we're going to talk about the mathematics of perspective in art we're going to find out the best place to stand in an art gallery uh the modern applications of the medieval chinese alternative to perspective and you're going to learn how to make your very own holbein inspired perspective illusion so it's almost exactly 600 years since philippo brunelleschi discovered the mathematical rules that underlie perspective and if we look at italian art that was being produced in the few years before that discovery we get these are beautiful beautiful pictures right so this is by duccio and you can see it's a lovely thing to look at but if you look closely at say this throne here that uh that mary is sitting on it doesn't look quite right in terms of the perspective another image of his here um you can look at the floor and again that's even more not quite right that isn't uh using correct perspective now these are great artists why aren't they using perspective why hadn't perspective been discovered sooner um and you know after the discovery we get these delightful pictures uh this one's by frau carnivale or the enunciation and you can see in all the perspectives just lovely and harmonious and beautifully correctly done this hadn't been discovered earlier i think partly because there wasn't as much need for it the style of art in pre-renaissance italy was more in the byzantine style it's it's it is stylized it's not supposed to be naturalistic in as much as you don't have the figures in realistic settings so much but when that started to come in and you started to want to put people in rooms on thrones then you really need to understand how am i going to portray this accurately so here comes philippe brunelleschi uh he as a many talented person architect sculptor he designed the dome of florence cathedral so he's shown in this picture with his uh picture for it this is a hugely impressive feat of engineering and architectural design and mathematics it's still the largest brick dome in the world so that's not not too shabby 600 years later as part of designing it and planning for it he actually he he's believed to be the person who had obtained the first ever patent in the world and it was for a huge boat called el badalone that could carry the vast slabs of marble required to build this uh magnificent building down the river arno and it needed a specially constructed boat and so he got this patent and no other new boat designs were allowed on the riverano for the following three years um actually don't tell anyone but the design didn't go too well they didn't actually even try it out until six years later and it sank so but he even vented the rules of linear perspective so well done to brunelski um one of the rules then and we can sort of feel intuitively that this is right by looking at uh photographs obviously something not not available to uh brunoleski to do but if you look at a photograph you see the parallel lines that are receding into the distance so not the verticals that are themselves parallel to the picture plane but the lines that proceed into the distance that are parallel look like they're all going to meet and converge on a point we call that point the vanishing point and if i've just drawn in some of those lines that's that is happening on this photograph now that's not a mathematical proof but it's sort of convincing evidence and it's a very good photograph because it draws our eye to this bus that is the subject so brunelski doesn't have a photo to look at um but he had did have a nice demonstration of this i'll show you in a second so that's one of the the rules that parallel lines um that are moving not within the plane of the picture should converge onto a single point called the vanishing point um now of course if you're trying to draw accurate pictures and if you're a good artist like giotto you can tell that lines that are parallel to each other like the ones in the ceiling of this picture here um some of which survives they they ought to kind of get closer together as they get further apart but if you follow the lines of those uh from this picture you find they sort of do but yeah they don't all meet in one point so this is kind of good artist uh a good artist drawing by eye and getting something about right but clearly that you know he is not following the rules of perspective there and they are not yet known but you can get approximately close by eye of course so i want to talk you through this vanishing point idea why do parallel lines um which clearly don't meet in real life i mean that's almost the definition of parallel right light parallel lines don't meet um so why on earth should they meet in a picture in an image um well they don't meet in real life but if you're looking at a real life picture or you're looking at a scene you know train tracks going to the distance they look like they're getting closer and closer and and perhaps they might meet but where they do meet we could say they meet at infinity but of course that's so far away we can't see it and it's vanished right so hence vanishing point so why why should that be true let me explain why it's true so when you're drawing a picture of course what you want to do is you're sort of imagining there's your eye e and you're looking through a window at the view and you want to replace that window instead with a picture that perfectly renders the view exactly so what you want to do is say there's a point over there the ray of light that's coming from the point to your eye will pass through the picture plane somewhere and that should be where you draw the image of your point right so it's just where the line from the point to your eye crosses over the picture plane that should be the image and i've called it p dashed and you can do that with all the other points there's another one q which has an image q dashed again it's where the line to your eye crosses the picture plane and so if you have then lines say the line pq it will have an image line p dash q dash jolly good surely good so far so good you know underlying this is the problem we're trying to solve is to represent the three-dimensional world we're going to try and project it onto two dimensions so this is one way of solving that problem so what about this vanishing point business well let's imagine then we have a bunch of parallel lines somewhere in your picture so these might be kind of the lines of floorboards proceeding into the distance or something like this so those blue lines they are all parallel to each other and they are not parallel to the picture plane so they're not no vertical lines would still remain parallel to each other but anything that isn't in that in that plane we expect to get closer together in our image so there's a bunch of parallel lines and i'm going to define a point for you now which is going to be our vanishing point and the way we define it is we say okay it is the line from our eye parallel to this collection of parallel lines and that is going to hit the picture plane somewhere let's call it the point v where it hits the picture plate so now the claim is that any image of any of these lines here these parallel lines that we're trying to draw any image line is gonna if we extend it suitably it's gonna hit that vanishing point so let's check that out so let's pick one of these lines pq if it works for this generic line it's going to work for all of them and we can draw our proposed vanishing point it's the line from our eye parallel to pq so we do that and it meets the picture plane at v now you've got these two parallel lines and in between them if you sort of drag one to the other it'll mark out a plane a flat plane with these two parallel lines and that plane slanted plane there is going to meet our picture plane and the intersection two planes is a line you can just see that line on the on the screen there now on that line we've got various things happening which points lie both on the red plane and on the picture plane well v does that's how we made v um and p dash the image of p and the image of q also lie on that line because they are precisely um the l where the line from e to p meets the picture line so that that's on the plane and so is q dash so therefore what have you got here you've got this line and it contains p dash q dash and v it contains the images the points and they all lie together on the line so if you just extend that line p dash q dash it has to go through the vanishing point and that argument is true we just took any old line right in that collection of parallel lines so we're done so that's why there is a unique vanishing point so brulesky was correct now he didn't have a photo to show his friends and draw lines on it what he did was uh he took a take snow prisoners building here this is the baptist tree in florence it's right next to the cathedral it is an octagonal building you could not ask for more straight lines in a building to draw to demonstrate perspective being correct i've just uh shown you a couple of well just one of the vanishing points there for that facade that's at 45 degrees on this octagonal building so what brunelleschi did was he painted a picture of the baptistry and he rigged up a little bit of kit so he took his picture actually it was a mirror image of the baptistry and he made a little hole in it and what he got people to do was stand precisely at the exact vantage point that he'd done the picture from and then they would look through a little pinhole through this picture and there was a mirror that you could gradually slide across in front of your view and the mirror would then show his picture gradually appearing and it was sort of covering over the real image they were looking at and they were exactly the same so this is a very compelling demonstration that the rules that he devised um you know the maths all works but sometimes people like to actually see it working you know for real so that was a very good demonstration so bruneski made these rules and he showed them to people and they caught on instantly so within five years it was 1421-ish 1420 that he came up with these rules as i say 600 years ago um within a few years this is 1427 approximately this painted by painting by masaccio tribute money it was using perspective the new rules so there are some parallel lines here in this in this picture you could see them coming down and up from the building and if you follow them to their to the end they all meet up at one point and of course because you can now make this kind of decision where do they meet where is the eye pushed to by all of these essentially arrows it's the most important figure in the in the painting that's jesus there with his disciples so you can choose then where to put your vanishing point that's another little trick so clearly this is someone who knows what the rules are and is applying them cleverly one other thing we can see from this picture is another of the rules of perspective that when you're drawing a group of people even though of course we know that as if you're looking at a view as people are further away they should appear to get smaller big things are close and smaller things are further away um there are all their heads are level so how can that be if it's all correctly in perspective well the reason all their heads are level is because if you think about what the what you're trying to do you're trying to project this three-dimensional thing onto two dimensions you are drawing lines from their eyes to your eye so if if we're all standing on level ground and if we're all roughly speaking the same height then then all of the eyes are roughly speaking at the same level as our eye the viewer so that's why they are all on this horizontal line so how how does that square with the figures seem should get smaller as they're further away well look at the feet this guy's close this guy's a bit further away feature a lot higher up so that's how that works so if you want to draw a nice group of figures in perspective the eye lines of all should be roughly the same there is a guy bending over in the background but you know he's he's bending over um now the rules of perspective were they were introduced by brunelleschi but they were popularized a lot by this chap leon batista alberti who wrote a book importantly in italian in the vernacular language and this meant it wasn't just for the intellectual elite um this is for the people who are actually making the art making the pictures de la petura and there was a latin version as well but but it was important that this version was in italian um and this spread the word even further and he he was an interesting guy he wrote a lot about um various different fields of of study architecture painting and he was very up on the link between mathematics and these other subjects mathematics is important for everything um he says i wrote you know in this commentary he which he dedicated to brunowski i'm going to tell you first the things that come from mathematics he said best things of course one thing alberti included in his book this is a picture from his book is how to deal with the problem of a tiled floor so we've already seen we know that the the kind of the parallel lines on the floor imagine uh square tiles on the floor the parallel lines that are receding back we know what to do with those they have a vanishing point but if you've got square tiles then the horizontal edges of those tiles are parallel to the picture so they remain parallel to each other they don't go off to a vanishing point the problem is that as we all know if we look at a tiled floor the tiles towards the back appear to be getting well they appear to be getting thinner but the gaps between them are getting smaller otherwise it looks wrong so you have to leave smaller and smaller gaps between these horizontal lines but how wide should the gaps be that is difficult to know because we don't we don't have a vanishing point for those however clever trick which alberti is describing in this diagram the diagonals of these square tiles are not parallel to the picture plane so they do all those parallel diagonals do have a vanishing point so here's the way to draw your tiled floor and you can all go home and do this tonight you get your your lines from front to back those edges you can just equally space some lines and make your vanishing point and that's done then you draw the first horizontal line and that's going to be your first square tile and you know depending on how much how quickly receding to the distance and the angles and everything you can basically choose and decree that to be square and then everything else has to match up with that first tile so how do you do that well you draw in all the diagonals i mean you can draw them in pencil and then rub them out later um draw them all in they would all go and meet a vanishing point so you find that vanishing point and then you can draw all these other diagonals based on the first row of tiles and then what have you got you've got a load of diagonal lines and you've got a load of front to back edges and every time an edge meets the diagonal what's that it's a corner so you acquire for yourself just from that first horizontal line you acquire for yourself a bunch more corners on the rows above so then you can draw in start to draw in the other horizontal rows and every new row you create allows you to join a few more diagonals and then you can draw a few more rows and over and over and over until you construct your whole floor so this was one of the diagrams that alberti drew and explained how to do this process so we can draw a tiled floor marvelous this is what suddenly it's sort of an epidemic of tiled floors in renaissance italian art by the way like if you look at a picture done in 1400 probably not a tile floor if you look at it in 1436 it's like 90 chance for child floor don't quote me on that 74.6 percent of statistics are made up on the spot so we've seen so far in all of our pictures um that there's sort of one clear vanishing point though there may be others hiding around in diagonals and things i just want to show you kind of three different ways of drawing a cube using perspective that are referred to as one point perspective two-point perspective three-point perspective even though all of these pictures really have many vanishing points in them if you join diagonals and things like that but these are the sort of the obvious ones so on the top left there you've got a cube where the face sort of square on literally um so you've got the the verticals and the horizontals are parallel to the picture and so they don't they stay parallel they don't have a vanishing point but the receding lines do so that's one point perspective the one in the bottom middle uh it's sort of like you know imagine a building on a street corner the verticals are still verticals they are parallel with the picture plane but you've got two receding to the left and to the right and so that would be two-point perspective so called because there's two obvious vanishing points and the one on the top right in that you might have a sort of bird's-eye view of a building or something like that that it has three vanishing points that are sort of clear to us as i've said in all of these there are there are many more um that you could find but these are perhaps the most obvious ones so if you're an artist you know how now to do your lovely perspective drawings for us who are viewers of art can these help us to appreciate art more well of course it's always nice to know how things were done but on a more practical level if you're in an art gallery we can if we understand these rules we can use them to try and work out where's the best place to stand to view a picture so starting with this you know this is not a great work of art this is just that cube i had a moment ago that has three point perspective so it's got these three vanishing points um and it's associated to these are associated to the receding lines off to the hang on your left uh and the ones off to the right the ones sort of to the left are have this vanishing point u the ones to the right have the matching point v and the ones that are going downwards have the vanishing point w um i want to convince you first you know how do we know where to stand uh to see this um i want to convince you first that there is a unique answer to this there's only one possible place we can stand to see this in its correct perspective um and then i'll show you how to actually find that place so we've got these three vanishing points now remember how we defined our vanishing points it's you stand you where your eye is when you're making the picture the line from your eye that's parallel to the appropriate collection of parallel lines right that hits the canvas at what we call the vanishing point so that point u that's associated to these parallel lines zooming off to the left so from our eye um the line to u is parallel to all of those and the line to v is parallel to all the lines zooming off to the right and the line to w is parallel to all the lines going downwards so at the point a correct vantage point you've got these three lines coming out and they are having exactly the same geometrical relationship to each other as what happens at the corner of the cube right they are all perpendicular to each other to the left to the right they're right angles in in the real world let's say this is you know just this is the perspective image but in reality with a cube these are all right angles and so those lines to the vanishing points have to also be at right angles to each other because that's how we define them so what you've got i'm just going to show you looking down on this image just at u and v and then the putative i that's supposed to be the ideal vantage point what you've got so there's my u and my v in the picture plane there's my i e and if we draw a triangle in now so the line from u to v the line from e to u and the line from e to v those have to be at right angles because the original sets of parallel lines were perpendicular so we've got a right angle triangle here now here comes the science bit think back to when you studied circle theorems at school do you remember a phrase coming back into your mind angles in a semicircle or 90 degrees or there's a right angle in a semicircle just flick back through the memory um the fact that this is the right angle here means the point e the i the ideal vantage point lies on a semi-circle with diameter uv so that's useful information of course we're living in three dimensions we don't know which semicircle because we could it could be you know at any kind of orientation so what we really know is that the ideal vantage point lies on the sphere with diameter uv it's somewhere on that sphere but we've got another vantage point sorry another vanishing point uh w and we could do exactly the same trick with the pair u and w the lines from them to to the vantage point to the eye have to be at right angles so this point e has to lie on the sphere with diameter uw and on the sphere with diameter vw so this ideal vantage point is not a great i tried to make it as visible as possible but it has to lie at the intersection of three spheres now three spheres that intersect do so at precisely two antipodal points north pole south pole right so this is one solution and this is another one now i've said i said it was a unique thing there's only one voltage point yeah that's because this other point is on the opposite side of the picture it's behind the picture inside the wall right so we can't stand there um so there really is only one answer there's only one place to see a perspective drawing from in in exactly the right place i mean if you stand near it you'll get a pretty good idea but there's one unique vantage point so okay fine you've shown us the three intersecting spheres sarah where do i stand in the art gallery okay here here you are in the art gallery you're looking at an old master where am i gonna stand to get the perfect perspective view of this um well let's let's remove the extraneous detail from this i.e everything that makes it amazing and have a slightly simpler thing to look at my amazing uh empty room perspective drawing um which i'm sure will be on display in the national gallery before too long so here we are looking at this where do we stand to get the best view of this amazing work of art well we can use what we know about vanishing points so um do not go up in an art gallery with a big ruler and make a big red blob on a vermeer don't say sarah hart told me i could i didn't but you can maybe do this you know home first or something or do it by eye you can work out where the vanishing point is for the lines of these tiles that go the edges that go front to back and for the diagonals one set of diagonals and then we can do a bit of thinking so this floor that's in the picture um should be if we're looking at it properly it should look like completely flat and level and horizontal like a floor and we're standing on a floor flat horizontal so any lines in that floor that's in the in the painting um they are all lying within that plane and remember the lines from our the perfect vantage point from our eye to the vanishing points have got to be parallel to all of those lines so they are all going to lie um they're going to be parallel but you know at the level of our eye so if we find that vanishing point she might need to stand on a little stool or something because her eye needs to be level with that vanishing point to get the perfect view and then so that's all right so so the eye has to be um along a line that's coming directly out of the picture somewhere from that vanishing point somewhere along that line so that's a start but how far along that line is the question well there's a bit more geometry we can do if you think about these diagonals and the straight lines going to the back they form a nice right angled triangle and it has 45 degree angles and so in particular the two sides this side and this side are the same length it's a nice leaf triangle so now think about what's happening the relationship between the the i being in its perfect place and the two vanishing points there we know that the the line from the eye to the vanishing point of the front to back lines and the eye the the line from the eye to the diagonal vanishing point they should be at the same angle that those lines are really at because they're supposed to be parallel to those original lines so they should be at a 45 degree angle and um you get the line that's coming out of the picture and the line within the picture between the two vanishing points those are right angles so you precisely get another of these 45 degree right angled triangles as it softly is again it looks a bit wonky because this is my perspective drawing of how to do perspective drawing so this green triangle up here also has to be an isosceles triangle in other words the distance from your eye to that vanishing point up here should equal the distance between the two vanishing points on the picture so that's how you can work out where to stand you stand directly in front of the vanishing point for the straight lines and at the same distance back from the canvas as distance between these two vanishing points so that's where you stand in art gallery okay so that's my one piece of advice now perspective was obviously very much employed and still is in art but it has a modern day application that brunelleschi 600 years ago was unlikely to have predicted i don't know for sure and that's in films so this is a still from a video that's up on youtube you can go and look at i've put the link in the transcript but it's by the company frame store who do visual effects for the paddington films which are glorious things to behold and you know this is computer-generated imagery what they do is they take they sort of mix together real-life video footage and then they add in extra bits that are difficult to produce in real life like a talking bear that eats marmalade sandwiches so this scene that they're showing here i've just got a couple of stills from it they've taken this video footage of you know a road in english countryside which of course you can see your perspective happening but they have to understand the rules of perspective in order to overlay onto it this fast moving train with lovely train tracks look at all those beautiful parallel lines receding into the distance is a very exciting chase on the top of the train between poor old paddington and the dastardly villain phoenix buchanan if i remember his name rightly who has played with considerable relish by by hugh grant so yeah worth watching um just for that but all of this requires knowing perspective and getting exactly right of course paddington himself is also uh has to be in perspective but he is harder to see underneath all that fur the correct the correct mathematics going on but it's there so we see it in modern films it's absolutely vital for for that to get the effects correct once you know the rules of perspective if we go back to art you can start using them in a way i've hinted at already which is to kind of make a point or to add to the symbolism of your pictures so we saw earlier that the uh the vanishing points of that picture by masaccio tribute money they all kind of joined the vanishing point was the face of of jesus he's the most important guy in the picture this picture uh which is by beneziano uh the another annunciation was on annunciation earlier by fraukhan valley uh you can see this beautiful perspective it's all very good this is uh the angel gabriel is announcing to mary that she is going to conceive a child miraculously and that child will be the son of god so where do you put your perspective where do you put your vanishing point in that picture you might think well it should be one of the two figures maybe um but if you look at where it is the vanishing point there is at this innocuous looking locked gate that keeps people out of the garden right so it's a locked gate and this is a symbol this is symbolic of mary's virginity right so that's an extra layer of symbolism to add to the you know emphasis of what's going on in this story that's a conscious decision um so veneziano obviously could wield the rules of perspective so if you look at this other picture by him saint xenobius performs a miracle given that he we know he knew the rules of perspective we've got this other you know almost contemporaneous picture by him showing using the world's perspective to impart symbolism if we look at this picture so what's this showing it's showing an absolutely distraught anguished confused distressed grieving mother whose child has died and saint xenobit is praying for the child to be restored to life um how do you use perspective then to emphasize what's going on in this picture well you know there was a perspective say everything meets at a vanishing point but they don't they don't quite meet and this gives us a sort of air of slight uh disconcertedness i suppose i i it surely must be done on purpose to emphasize the the action of the scene this confusion and grief of the mother so you can use it and you can you know you can deliberately not get it right if you want to send that message um you can also trick people so you can use perspective effects to make people think what they're seeing is not what is really there so this is uh called a fourth perspective gallery it's in rome and here it looks very very much longer than it really is it looks like it's about 20 meters long but it's actually been cleverly designed to look longer and it's really only eight meters long i think because they've used the rules of perspective you know these aren't really parallel lines but you just assume they are much later we get you know people like hogarth famous satire and false perspective this was at the um beginning this is the frontier piece of a booklet on perspective that his friend uh uh joshua kirby had written and i've just i've just sort of say enlarged the writing that's at the bottom of this whoever makes a design without the knowledge of perspective will be liable for such absurdities as are shown in this frontish piece and if we look um i want to make sure everyone is sort of at the back can see but there are various absurdities indeed in this picture it's got an in in the foreground and then various things happening in the background that couldn't it doesn't quite write doesn't quite look right locally all looks okay like if you look at any little bit it looks okay but then if you look at the whole impossible things start to happen and perhaps the most obvious of these is that uh if you look at the top there's someone hanging out of the the window of the inn with a candle and she's lighting the pipe of the chap who's on the far distant hill you should be completely unable to actually do this but you know it all looks right just it doesn't doesn't work globally this is the kind of trick you can do if you're a master of perspective um and of course more recently we have the work of artists like escher who have got kind of uh waterfalls whose water from them feeds into themselves and you know stairs that go forever upwards and things like this that again trick us by making us believe in the perspective locally that then falls down globally now you could very sensibly ask what's going on elsewhere so why we we sort of saw why there might be an impetus for perspective to be discovered in relations italy when people wanted to turn to a more naturalistic style of painting what was happening elsewhere was this discovered elsewhere if not why not and usually with these kind of things and it's true here it's not because there was you know a particular i mean there was a particular genius happening in renaissance italy but it's it's not that there weren't geniuses elsewhere in the world right it's because different forms of art have different challenges that require different solutions so there's some evidence that there was at least personal knowledge partial knowledge of the rules of perspective in ancient greek and roman art what knowledge there was though was lost and had to be rediscovered we will never know if they knew all the rules or not certainly weren't written down but in if you look at ancient egyptian art this is it's it's a solution to a problem that isn't there because the art is not supposed to be naturalistic it's it's hierarchical it represents things not in a realistic way i mean just look at the way the bodies are we have this convention that the torsos are all front-facing the legs are always sideways side profiles of all the heads um and big things are not does not mean they're close and far and far away things are not small bigness size um is to do with how important you are so the gods are the biggest things in the picture then it will be the the nobles and then you know right at the bottom of the pile the slave will be painted very small that does not mean that they are far away okay so this symbolic almost painting um there's no need to develop perspective because that's not what you're trying to achieve and here this is a painting in a tomb you know you've got is this this is not kind of still life with fishes this is here's all the stuff we've sent you to the afterlife with and you have to be able to see it all so you know that that's not realism is not what's the aim what the aim is here if you move forward in time if you look at what's happening in chinese and in japanese art about the time of the renaissance in italy why in the perspective discovered there well because it would be totally irrelevant to the art forms that were there reason if you're a 15th century chinese painter you are probably painting um a very long painting along a scroll that tells a story as you move along the picture just have a piece of water oh there's one to look at while i have a sip of water so this is actually a picture made in 1820ish by the japanese artist hiroshige and it's a picture of a kabuki theater you can see that what is happening here is not our linear perspective that we've been talking about and there's a good reason for that if you're painting a long scroll some of these scrolls could be 10 meters or more where's the vantage point there is no vantage point your eye is constantly moving along along the design as it tells a story so perspective just isn't the solution here it's not going to work it's not an appropriate thing if you did try to have a fixed vantage point then the ends would be hopelessly distorted and you're not going to see so you want a solution where your eye can move along the picture and not have a fixed voltage point and this is the solution that was developed very ingenious in english we call it axonometric projection and you can see what happens here is parallel lines stay parallel the angles between them that so you know this this would be a right angle in real life and it's portrayed as not a right angle but that's that's the concession that's made and the distance is all that the size of the figures there's no diminution as you move into the background and things don't grow bigger as they go into the foreground they're the same size so it gives you this sort of panoramic viewpoint and that is really really useful actually in some modern day applications it's very ingenious solution to the question of how we portray something so it has been exploited by modern artists such as roger brown for example and then some other chicago artists were were exploring these ideas in the in the 70s 80s um and you could see this this here are these two parallel roads they are not getting closer together as you proceed into the distance it gives this slight air of unreality but it also is sort of a democratic way of showing things the figures aren't getting smaller further away they are everyone's got their own an egalitarian perspective in these kind of pictures you can move around and there's no single vantage point there's important technical applications too though um in technical drawings this is a patent application um from the 1880s i think so this is done in axonometric projection what's useful here is that we've said you know there's no diminution inside as you go forwards and backwards along axes the scaling factor is constant so axonometric actually comes from words meaning measurement by the axes you could actually take measurements from this picture even though it's showing a three-dimensional object um you can take measurements from it and that's important obviously with a technical drawing or an architectural drawing there are more symmetrical versions of axonometric projection so isometric projection which is a word we may be slightly more familiar with that means it's the same scaling factor along each axis so that's the easiest one to use because you just need to know what the scaling factor is then you can take measurements and get retrieve um what you need to make this design the most symmetrical form of isometric projection is where the angles between the axes are all the same 120 degrees and you may have seen or used isometric uh drawing paper which allows you to make 3d looking drawings diagrams like this not very good one i've done here just to show you so this is kind of a lattice of equilateral triangles it allows you to get those 120 degree angles um between the three axes and so this this this old technology or idea of of axonometry projection has gotten modern very modern applications and there's one that you know perhaps it's really quite unexpected given this is developed to solve the problem of huge long painted scrolls we don't look at huge long painted scrolls depicting uh invented worlds anymore but we do look at some invented worlds and if anyone wastes time playing phone games which where you have worlds and you build them and you add buildings in and you move trees around and things like that not waste time spends time relaxing then you'll be familiar with themes like this right so this one is called big farm but they're all very similar you you build a world and you can move around in the world and it's really really useful to be able to have not real perspective but this axonometric perspective where everything stays the same size and it doesn't matter for which place you're looking at it because sometimes you want to move things around go can i build a big barn in that space and you check and you can and you know you can because you see it here and it's going to stay the same size when it moves over there so moving around in these imagined worlds is something that modern games do all the time and so this is an absolutely you know vital bit of the technology in it that enables us to do this and it comes from these medieval uh these medieval scrolls and that solution there so say that was the right solution for that art form and linear perspective was the right solution for the the italian renaissance so we're going through a little while we're going to talk about the sort of strange perspective illusions uh of the sort that holbein created but just before we do i want to mention um that the mathematics we've seen so far it's it's got some geometry in its circles squares uh triangles but it's it's mathematics that was understood um you know by 600 euro people however this has had a huge effect on modern mathematics far beyond what you might expect from looking at what we've talked about so far and the reason is because it set it kind of put a seed in people's minds with this crucial observation that these parallel lines we're talking about meet at infinity and so that's why when we have the image of them they're meeting at the vanishing point and at some point it sort of became and it gives a sort of respectability to infinity all these parallel lines a collection of parallel lines they will all have a point at infinity where they meet and sort of a step you can then take once you're comfortable with that idea it say well let's let's sort of incorporate this point at infinity into our geometry so we've got all the sort of standard points in space we'll just throw in all these points at infinity one for each collection of parallel lines i'm going down that route things that's a bit weird why do that it it gives you this very nice duality and simplicity to some of the rules of geometry so we all know mathematicians like universal rules right we all know the rule that says any pair of lines meet in exactly one point oh except if they're parallel we don't like except if we like everything to be true you know we like it a universal rule so with this pointed infinity idea you can do that any pair of lines meets an exactly one point and the ones that we call parallel the meeting point is the point at infinity okay so that's quite nice you can just say that is true and you can also go in reverse you can say that any pair of points define precisely one line so if these points are in sort of normal space you just draw the line between them that's exactly one of those job done if one of the points is a one of these points at infinity that you've just added into the mix then what do you do well this it's basically the parallel postulate because that point at infinity that's connected to a collection of parallel lines that's how we define these points at infinity so it is the point where all these lines that are parallel to each other meet here's your other point over here through any point there is exactly one line parallel to your favorite line over here that passes through that point so if you have a point infinity that gives you a direction for the parallel lines and then there's exactly one of those that goes through your favorite point over here so any two points do define a unique line so with this idea you've got this nice it sort of simplifies things a bit but it also gives you a really elegant way to do some kinds of mathematics some kinds of geometry and i just want to give you one minute about conic sections which these are you may may or may not recognize them slight advert for later in the year i'm doing a talk all about conic sections so you should definitely sign up for that come to that but in the meantime um on the left you've got an ellipse in the middle you've got a parabola on the right you've got a hyperbola now these three curves are not randomly joined together linked and called conic sections they are curves you get by slicing through a cone so if you take a sort of shallow slice you get an ellipse and if you go a bit further you start to get a parabola and then if you go even further still and cut into sort of the top half of the cone you get hyperbolas so these curves are linked to cones but they don't seem very similar to each other it's sort of weird they're connected somehow because they you can make them by slicing through something but they don't seem to have much in common however with this amazing projective geometry idea of adding in points at infinity you can treat these in a very elegant way and analyze them all in one go and the reason is that say look at this guy this is a hyperbola it's got two branches to it and and the ends of each branch zoom off to infinity but they zoom off in two ways uh two of the ends zoom off and become sort of parallel to the vertical line so they'll join up they'll meet up at the point in infinity corresponding to vertical lines meanwhile the other two branches the other two ends of the branches zoom off to horizontal infinity so they'll meet at a different point at infinity so this guy meets infinity twice what does the parabola do it's n zoom off to infinity and they become you know closer and closer to vertical so they join up at infinity at one point the point where vertical lines meet so what's that got to do with anything well if you take an ellipse here we know that any line you can draw cuts an ellipse either not at all or exactly once if it's just kind of a tangent to it or exactly twice these three curves i claim are they're all ellipses really they're all ellipses really but the true ellipse meets the line at infinity made up of all those points in zero points the parabola meets the lines infinity in exactly one point the vertical uh vanishing point and the hyperbola is an ellipse that meets the lines infinity in exactly two places and you can actually it sounds a bit sort of pie in the sky but you can actually do this kind of analysis and understand all of these curves are just variations of the same curve that just meet infinity in a different number of places so that's super super cool um study geometry it's marvelous to finish though in the in the five-ish minutes we have before i'd like to have some time for questions um i want to talk about pictures like this so anamorphic perspective this is where you get perspective views in unexpected ways so it's still perspective as we've talked about it in your perspective but this picture here oh i'm oh gosh i happen to be standing it's almost exactly the right place to see this properly but you guys aren't so let me show you if you look at this from the right vantage point this funny blob at the bottom of holbein's picture this is what you get right a skull sort of memento mori remember that you two are mortal there it is so it's a sort of hidden thing to show people um there were a few of these around um that sort of time so this very elongated picture it's hard to see what it is but again if you look at it from the far right hand side you find that it's a picture if my clicker will work yes it's a picture of edward vi but you have to look at it from the right angle other kinds that we haven't really talked about uh perspective or pictures you can make by reflecting in mirrors but you can hide pictures with this kind of trick perspective or anamorphic it's called making things anew that's the root of that word um if there's a picture that perhaps it might be dangerous for you to have in your house for example at certain times in history you may not have wanted to be caught with a picture of bonnie prince charlie to pretend into the throne in your house then what you do is you make a picture that can only be seen correctly when you reflect it in a cylindrical mirror and then if someone comes knocking on the door quick put the cylindrical mirror somewhere else and what is left is just looks like a tray with a smear of paint on it so you can hide your your treasonous portraits of people you think should be king in this way um more recently much more recently in the current era we see anamorphic perspective which really is you know it's normal perspective but unexpectedly done um in things like sports advertising where there's a picture that's painted directly onto the pitch and it's done in such a way it looks totally wrong from pitch level but it's meant to it's meant for the tv cameras if you're at the correct vantage point which is the camera then it appears to be you know in exactly the right dimensions and it appears upright even though of course it isn't because we can't impede the action on the on the pitch a good place to see this is in cricket matches because then you can see at the top of the very top of the pitch um that there were two cameras you see because in cricket as you probably know at the end of each over you have to change the end from which you bowl from so there has to be a camera at this end and then one at the other end of the pitch for when they change the direction of bowling so we can see we're at the point of the camera at the bottom we can see these two adverts all nicely rendered just perfect for us in the right perspective for our view but at the back of the picture you could see the adverts that are intended to be seen correctly by the other camera and of course they look completely distorted now artists who produce work that is meant to be site specific that only exists you know in a particular place have exploited this anamorphic perspective to produce really compelling and really curious pictures so this is these three pictures but just look at the top one for the moment this is by the french artist uh phillis farini those nine dancing triangles they're called are viewed from the correct vantage point it looks just like you know i've got a picture and just put on top of it superimposed some pictures of triangles it can't be real i mean it just looks so incongruous um but actually the pictures below show that same room but you know not from the correct vantage point you see these kind of blobs of red paint and it doesn't look like anything and then just it's magic you stand in the right place and you see these triangles that leap out in front of you so that's very clever uh bit of a trick to pull off um this one so go and go and look up this guy rustpop on youtube because he he makes these amazing actually i don't know if it's he they make amazing anamorphic illusions um which i'll put a link in there in the transcript so this for example um just looks like a rubik's cube on a table uh until the hand of creator comes in and rotates a piece of paper and it's just a flat piece of paper just cleverly done with the rules of perspective so i want to show you in two minutes um how you can make uh a picture that is like one of those holbein stretchy out skulls so what's happening in in in these kind of pictures is you imagine you've got a design i'm going to say for simplicity a square design that you want to put onto a picture this is the picture plane like usual and you want the viewing point to be very far over to the right hand side so that someone looking at it straight on is not going to see the distorted picture so you'll take your square design and this will be the projection of it or the perspective image of it is going to be sort of stretched out and the square will look a bit like a trapezium i guess stretched out like that and you want to stand very very close you want to only see it quickly from very close um to the to the picture itself to the picture plane so i've made a one or two assumptions just to make it a bit easier to to produce for us so one is um all of the things that are happening that we're trying to represent in our picture are happening on this horizontal plane at the top and so all the vanishing points will also they'll they'll be at the ends of lines from your eye that are parallel to that horizontal plane so where does the horizontal plane meet this plane um well it meets it in a vertical line and then how close you stand to the picture determines you know where the vanishing points are going to be so i've made an assumption um so here is the distorted square there's the vanishing point of all the horizontal lines in the square top edge bottom edge middle and i've assumed that the eye is going to be just at that level so it's nice and symmetrical and the other assumption i've made is that we're standing at the correct distance from the picture so that the vanishing points of diagonal lines are going to be going to be these i've called them c and d they have a diagonal lines from top left to bottom right from bottom left to top right i have assumed that the vertical line they lie on that the distance is there make this into just a rectangle a b c d is a rectangle okay that's that makes the algebra pleasing so divide this rectangle in half here and that's what this z is like the middle of the big rectangle and we want to find out how we're going to distort our square in other words we stretch it a bit and we have to squash the right hand side how long is this line x y where is it similar triangles come to the rescue the two red triangles are similar you've got these vertically opposite angles and you've got the alternating angles or z angles some people call them so the angle a is equal to the angle of v the angle at b is equal to the angle at d so these are similar triangles and one is twice as big as the other so this small red one is half the height of the big red one so the big red triangle is double the little one which means that this point x is twice as far from the left as it is from the right so it's two thirds of the way along two to one ratio and you can do a similar thing with the gold triangles they're they're similar triangles as well but the bottom one it's half the width of the top so this distance to x from the top is twice the distance from x to the midpoint of our big rectangle so putting all that together and you know take a symmetrical argument on the other side for that point y what you end up with is that this square should be distorted in this way it's got whatever height it is on the left it'll be a third that height on the right and actually we can lose the rectangle that was only for construction this is the shape you need to make so there are photo editing programs you can get either free online or you can pay for them if you like and all you need to do is take your square image stretch it as far as you like we didn't need to know what the width of the rectangle was doesn't come out in the final calculation so that's cool you should stretch as far as you like and then squish the right hand side down so that it's a third of the height of the hole and i've put one of these in the transcript for you to play with but i made one and you can yeah however get it from transcript this is a mysterious person who is very relevant to the history of this college and i just want to show you um i could just show you the original picture but that wouldn't prove this worked i made a very bad video of me cut it out stuck it on my wall and tried to get the right vantage point and i don't know if you can see this happening but this figure should appear right and of course it's uh thomas gresham so on that note i will finish i hope i've given you sorry for this a new perspective on perspective thank you question are there any examples of cave art with perspective uh i never like to say a firm no but i'm not aware of any i think perhaps cave art is very symbolic you know here's here's the saber-tooth tiger here's some people i don't think i'm happy to be corrected but i believe not and do these principles does this apply to military camouflage schemes for example ship dazzle patterns i'm gonna say yes my feeling is that uh you know if you're trying to create something that will fool an observer you've got to get your perspective right so i'm sure you you need to deploy some of those techniques the only the thing with i'm not sure exactly what ship dazzle schemes are to be fair but one issue might be you've got to be careful if you're using linear perspective where's the vantage point so there are kind of trick uh rooms for example that you can make they're called aims rooms where it's a very compelling illusion that the room is properly in perspective and you can and these were used actually you know in the filming of the the lord of the rings films where you have hobbits that are small and wizards that are big in the same room and they created these kind of trick perspective rooms to make those people look very much different in size in what looked like a normal room so maybe there are tricks like that that can be used in those contexts but of course it requires knowing what the vantage point is going to be back to the massachusetts slide please i yes yeah so i don't know how clear it it how easy you know how easy how visible it is um from the audience there were some you can have a look through there was a building um oh there we go so there's there is a building it's quite you know the resolution isn't perfect but there are lines from the floor of the building the tiles are building another one here and then at the higher up level you can see where the second floor of the building is is that there are some lines there uh coming down and so if i just put those back on can you see now like from the corners of the building um that's where they're coming from so there are some straight lines in the picture they come from the corners because um the other lines that come off from their horizontal lines so looking at the building straight on you've got horizontal lines and then it goes back so the horizontal lines are not parallel to those ones that i've drawn so they wouldn't have a vanishing point it's only collections of lines that are all parallel to each other that have a a single shared vanishing point so we could join if there might be other lines again they can't be parallel to the to the whole picture otherwise they stay so the horizontal lines would not have a vanishing point but it's only the ones therefore that are receding into the distance that i've been able to draw a vanishing point on for this picture i presume when they started this painting with knowledge all the tiles were parallel to the plane of the picture how long did it take before they got the rules right so they gave an arbitrary tiled fraud yeah so it took a while and i'm thinking the kind of the zenith of this might have been the the old masters and paintings in the netherlands that came a little bit later a century and a half later or so that are just absolutely amazing i'm thinking of there's one uh picture of a cathedral it's got these vertical columns and it's got square tile floor and the effect is absolutely amazing but it's not straight on so there are these diagonal lines so i would say i know i'm not an art historian but i would say i would think it took maybe 100 years for that to become sort of a commonplace thing and initially people were like hey tiled floors you just get a lot of tiled floors but but it does it does move on from that and of course modern times you get that the building at the corner of the street is a very common trope after a while as well yeah what the channel 4 tv logo graphics application be an example of some of the points you've been making have you seen this one where the the um there are bits of the four yeah that move around and then they it becomes a four from a certain perspective yes absolutely and and i'm thinking something we sometimes drive past on the north circular there's a kind of sculpture outside of one of the shopping centers that from a certain exact angle looks exactly like a football and then when you drive past it the illusion is completely shattered or a penrose triangle if you've seen those actual sculptures of them they look of course they can't exist in real life but they look real from a certain angle so absolutely those kind of things certainly require the understanding perspective okay well i think we're going to have to draw it to a close there thank you so much professor hart [Applause]
Up Next

The Lewis Collection: Modern Masters of the Human Figure
@sothebys
417 views•2026-06-10

Klimt, Schiele, and Kokoschka: Portrayals of Women
@belvederemuseum
25.3K views•2015-11-17

Ukiyo-e Art: History, Woodblock Printing & Influence
@japanathand
6.3K views•2023-06-08

Earliest Depictions of Jesus in Art: 10 Ancient Images Explained
@UsefulCharts
5.9M views•2022-06-03
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Art History















![The ITALIAN Renaissance, EXPLAINED [AP Euro, Unit 1 Topic 2 (1.2)]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/7y-zYnr3xoI/maxresdefault.jpg)
![[랜선투어 - 작품설명] 루브르 미술관 랜선투어 - 1부](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/I0flkqkCdNc/maxresdefault.jpg)

















![[TOP 5] LEGJOBB ASZFALTRAJZ művész ■ 3D aszfaltrajzok, amitől leesik az állad [5LEG]](https://i.ytimg.com/vi_webp/nXTjGg1HkEI/maxresdefault.webp)




