Hobbes's Defense of Absolute Monarchy in Leviathan

Added:

Lockean Liberalism and Limited Government

John Locke’s 'Two Treatises of Government' serves as the primary counterpoint to Hobbes’s defense of absolute monarchy. While Locke agrees with the premise of a social contract arising from a state of nature, he strongly rejects absolute rule. Locke argues that an absolute monarch, possessing unchecked power with no impartial judge to resolve disputes between themselves and their subjects, essentially remains in a state of nature relative to those subjects. Therefore, absolute monarchy is not a cure for the state of nature, but a worsening of it. Instead, Locke advocates for a limited, constitutional government based on the consent of the governed, the protection of natural rights (life, liberty, and property), and the separation of powers. Crucially, Locke introduces the right to revolution, asserting that if a government fails to protect these rights or becomes tyrannical, citizens have the moral right to overthrow it. This perspective directly challenges Hobbes's view that sovereignty must be indivisible and absolute to prevent chaos.

The concept of the 'State of Nature' as defined by political philosophers, representing human existence prior to the establishment of formal government.
The historical context of the English Civil War (1642-1651), which profoundly influenced Hobbes's views on political instability, chaos, and human nature.
The fundamental premise of Social Contract Theory, wherein individuals collectively agree to surrender some freedoms to a ruling authority in exchange for security and order.
John Locke’s counter-arguments in 'Two Treatises of Government,' which advocate for limited government, natural rights, and the right to revolution.
The development of the 'separation of powers' doctrine by Baron de Montesquieu as a direct structural challenge to Hobbes’s insistence on indivisible sovereign power.
Modern political debates concerning the trade-off between national security and individual civil liberties, such as state surveillance and emergency executive powers.
An analysis of how modern authoritarian regimes use security-based, neo-Hobbesian arguments to justify the suppression of democratic institutions.
134K views6.1Klikes12:21@AcademicAgentOriginal Release: 2019-04-10

Thomas Hobbes, in Chapter 19 of his 1651 work Leviathan, argues that absolute monarchy is superior to democracy and aristocracy based on six key reasons: (1) the monarch's private interests align with public interests since the monarch's wealth depends on his subjects' prosperity, whereas elected officials may enrich themselves at others' expense; (2) monarchs can receive rational, secret counsel while assemblies are prone to emotional arguments and leaks; (3) monarchs can maintain consistent long-term policies while assemblies are inherently fickle and prone to reversing decisions; (4) monarchs cannot disagree with themselves, reducing the risk of civil war; (5) assemblies have exponentially more flatterers enabling corruption; and (6) assemblies create a permanent state of court intrigue similar to having an infant king, with everyone competing to become Lord Protector.