Bernard Williams on Immortality: The Makropulos Case | Philosophy Lecture 9

Added:

John Martin Fischer's Defense of Immortality

In contrast to Bernard Williams’ pessimistic view that eternal life would inevitably lead to crushing boredom, philosopher John Martin Fischer argues that immortality can be highly desirable. Fischer challenges Williams by distinguishing between 'self-exhausting' pleasures (which, once experienced, lose their appeal) and 'repeatable' pleasures. Repeatable pleasures—such as appreciating art, enjoying music, scientific discovery, and cultivating deep relationships—do not lose their value over time and can continuously renew our desire to live. Furthermore, Fischer argues that our psychological and intellectual capacities could adapt, allowing us to cultivate new 'categorical desires' over an infinite lifespan. Rather than being condemned to a tedious, static existence, an immortal individual could lead a rich, evolving, and active life filled with ongoing projects, making eternal life not only tolerable but deeply meaningful.

The philosophical distinction between categorical desires (which give us reasons to go on living) and conditional desires (which assume we are already alive).
Basic theories of personal identity over time, specifically the role of memory, character, and psychological continuity in defining the self.
Traditional philosophical perspectives on the badness of death, such as Epicurean deprivation theory and Lucretius's symmetry argument.
Familiarity with thought experiments in ethics and metaphysics, and how literature (like Karel Čapek's play 'The Makropulos Affair') is used to explore philosophical ideas.
John Martin Fischer's counterarguments to Williams, specifically his classification of 'repeatable' versus 'self-exhausting' pleasures in an infinite life.
The bioethics of radical life extension, analyzing the social, economic, and ethical implications of transhumanism and life-prolonging technologies.
Existentialist views on mortality and meaning, particularly Martin Heidegger's assertion that death is necessary to give life urgency and structure ('being-towards-death').
The distinction between secular/biological immortality and theological/metaphysical conceptions of eternal existence (e.g., heaven, reincarnation, or timelessness).
1.1K views30likes57:47@krladerouteOriginal Release: 2020-05-20

Bernard Williams argues that personal immortality is antithetical to a meaningful human life because an immortal existence would eventually exhaust our categorical desires (those that give us reasons to live beyond mere survival), leading to boredom and loss of purpose; for life to be meaningful, it must have an endpoint that prevents this exhaustion, making death potentially welcome rather than always evil.