Thomas Nagel argues that death is intrinsically bad because it deprives us of life, which is intrinsically good; he responds to Epicurus' objection that death cannot be bad since we don't experience it by showing that death is bad in contrast to the alternative of continued life, and he addresses the symmetry argument by distinguishing between extending life forward (which preserves our identity) and backward (which would not be 'us'), ultimately concluding that death is always a deprivation regardless of when it occurs.
Thomas Nagel on Death: The Deprivation Account
Added:the ancient Greek philosopher epicurus argues that death is not a bad thing and not something that we should fear right on but in an influential paper from 1970 the American philosopher Thomas Nagel argues that death is intrinsically bad what he says that having a life is intrinsically good and death is something that deprives us of life and so as a deprivation of the good of Life Death is intrinsically bad what do you think of that argument Scully I think that life is a deprivation of death Thomas Nagel's 1970 paper death is one of the most influential papers on the topic of death in the analytic tradition of philosophy this is sort of the anglo-american tradition of philosophy in the last 100 years and Nel's paper is important in particular for articulating what's come to be known as a deprivation account of the Badness of death so Nel thinks that it's bad to die or rather it's bad to be dead but there's a problem that we've already looked at uh that's presented originally by epicurus with the idea of saying that death is a bad thing because I'm not around when I'm dead so how could it possibly be bad for me there's no me there to suffer the Badness of my death and nagle's argument is to say that death is bad you might say in contrast to the Alternatives you know if I were to die next year that would be a worse way to spend next year than spending next year alive that what it would mean for me to die next year is that I would be deprived of all those future years that I might otherwise have been able to live out and so the thought with Nagel's argument is when we want to consider the goodness or Badness of something happening we don't want to just consider that thing in its own right but we want to consider it in contrast with the Alternatives and in particular while I might not be around when I'm dead to than gosh it's too bad I'm dead I can While I'm Alive think well if if I'm given the choice between being alive next year and being dead next year I would prefer to be alive next year so in that sense there's a contrasting case in contrast with which my death would be a bad thing and in that sense death counts as a deprivation of life now Nel recognizes that for his argument to be compelling he needs to be able to address and respond to arguments from EP from epicurus and from lucus to the effect that death is not a bad thing and he offers three possible objections from the epicurian position that he thinks he has answers to the first is a basic premise of the epicurian argument which is that the only things that can be good or bad for me are those things that I experience so the thought then for epicurus is I don't experience being dead so dead can't be bad for me and Nel says look there's a whole bunch of things that can be bad for you even though you don't experience them imagine having people make fun of you behind your back or imagine your partner is cheating on you behind your back you might be blissfully unaware that this is going on but nevertheless is bad for you now one possible epicurian reply would be to say nothing's going wrong in your life while you're being cheated on because you don't know it's happening it's only when you find out that you start to experience Misfortune and Nel's point I think is a reasonable one where he says the reason it hurts to find out you've been cheated on is because it's bad to be cheated on if it weren't bad to be cheated on it wouldn't hurt to find out and so the thought there is that the bad thing is already happening before you find out you might add actually and he doesn't say this but if it were the case that it's the finding out that's bad rather than the being cheated on that's bad when your friend tells you that your partner is cheating on you you should rightly be angrily at the friend who told you who made you unhappy rather than the partner who was cheating on you but that doesn't seem to be right it does seem that were upset about the thing that was happening rather than the finding out that happened so that's the first objection the second objection he considers is the thought that one difference between being cheated on or ridiculed on the one hand and being dead on the other is that there's still a me who is being cheated on or being ridiculed but when I'm dead there's no me so I can't be worse off because there's no me around to suffer The Misfortune and here he gives the example of an intelligent person who suffers a catastrophic brain injury and was reduced to the mental state of a contented infant so this person according to the hypothesis is happy they're cheerful they're not having any bad experiences they're sort of cing like a baby in their hospital bed but nevertheless it seems like it's right to say that the person has experienced a great Misfortune even though in some sense that person is no longer there the person who I used to engage in all sorts of lively conversations about art and culture and politics is in some sense effectively gone but nevertheless there is this person in the hospital bed cing like an infant and I can think he has suffered or she has suffered some great Misfortune so in some sense I can say that something bad has happened to somebody even though to all its intents and purposes that person is gone and then the third argument he wants to address is the Symmetry argument from lucretius so lucretius says look you don't feel any kind of fear and horror about the period of non-existence before you were born so why do you feel any fear and horror about the period of non-existence after you're dead and Nel says there's an important asymmetry here that I could reasonably wish that I could have more life beyond whatever allotted years I'm going to get uh I could wish that my life could be extended in the future Direction but he thinks that it makes less sense to wish that my life could be extended in the past direction to wish that I could have been born sooner and his reason for saying that is that if I had been born sooner it wouldn't in some sense be me who was born if I had been born in the 1920s you you know same genetic makeup all the rest same person to some extent um I would have been born into a different world I would have different set of experiences and some sense it wouldn't be me who would be getting more life now this argument raises I think some thorny issues in the philosophy of personal identity and I'm not going to get into them in this short video but it does raise some interesting questions about what exactly makes me me in a way that would make my uh being born earlier or later uh the life of somebody else rather than me now there's a central premise to nagle's argument in his deprivation account which is that having a life is good so he wants to say that you know life has its ups and downs it's good experiences it's bad experiences but in addition to that there is the fact of having a life and having a life is itself a good thing such a good thing that even if most of your experiences are bad being alive is a net positive because having a life outweighs all the bad experiences within it and he doesn't offer that much in the way of an argument for this premise you know he says a few things about how you know it's it's good to be able to have experiences and all of the rest but I think there's a a reasonable question to ask whether having a life as distinct from all the experiences within a life can itself be a good thing and in particular I think there's two contrasting uh positions you could take here you could say that having a life is a neutral matter it's the experiences that count so I think this is roughly the epicurian position where they want to say good experiences are good bad experiences are bad but they don't place any particular weight on the simple fact of having a life whereas Nel wants to say that having a life is a good thing the other position you could take is a pessimistic one and I think this is maybe most famously represented by the German philosopher Arthur schopenhauer who wants to say that having a life is a net negative that it's bad that life is conditioned by suffering and it's shaped by the volition that we have the the force of will that drives us constantly to strive and to want things in a way that causes suffering for ourselves and others he takes himself to be drawing significantly on uh Indian and Buddhist philosophy here it's unclear to what extent this accurately represents the Indian philosophical traditions shopen Hower was writing in the early 19th century when scholarship in Europe on Indian philosophy was a little thin but there's at least an argument there to be entertained that contrary to Nagel's point that having a life is a net positive someone like schopenhauer might say that a life is a net negative and one thing schopenhauer shares with Buddhist uh philosophy is the idea that the goal of life is not to achieve things but rather to achieve the extinction of the will to get to a point where you were no longer driven by your will now there's a question that Nagel raises right at the end of his paper so he's arguing on the whole that life is a good thing so the deprivation of life is a bad thing and then he asks is this always the case so he contct conts the poet John Keats who died at the age of 26 with the novelist Leo teloy who lived to be 82 and he says it seems intuitive to say that keats's death was more of a tragedy than tell sto that Kei somehow was deprived of more than T sto was and so then there's a question that you know it seems natural to say that there's something bad there's something sad about somebody dying young think of all the years that kei's missed out on think of all the great poetry we missed out on um whereas you know T sto lived to a ripe old age he had a lot of great achievements it's not like there was like some further great novel in the offing that might have come about maybe there was I don't know um but we somehow think of it as less of a tragedy so then there's a question of is it nevertheless a deprivation for T stoy to have died when he did and N ultimately comes down on the side of yes that it is a deprivation and not only is it too bad for tell stoy but as long as we're alive as long as long as being alive having a life is a good thing being deprived of more life is a bad thing and there are obviously exceptional cases where somebody's life is so bad that they would choose to end it and there's a whole philosophical debate around the ethics of euthanasia but for the most part even very old people have reason to want to go on living and so according to Nel it is a deprivation of life and a bad thing no matter how old you are and so he gets to the point of saying that if this is the case if it's the case that no matter when you die uh you're being deprived of more life and so your death is a bad thing he says in that case a bad end awaits all of us if you like this video or found it useful please do give it a a thumbs up on YouTube I don't have any thumbs or alternatively or in additionally maybe you could follow this YouTube channel I appreciate all the likes and all the follows thank you
Up Next

Epicurus on Death: Is Death Bad? Philosophy of Mortality
@autodidactstoolkit
5.6K views•2016-04-06

The Arcades of Paris: Walter Benjamin on Urban Politics & Philosophy
@internationalcentreforcont7204
2.3K views•2013-06-19

Should We Destroy the Machines? Big Tech Surveillance Critique
@TheStoriesWeTell303
167.9K views•2025-11-30

The Myth of Sisyphus: A Greek Legend of Eternal Punishment
@TEDEd
8.6M views•2018-11-13
Related Study Plans & Knowledge Roadmaps
Structured learning paths in Philosophy



































