Torts: Strict Liability Explained | Law & Bar Exam Review

Added:

Fault-Based Liability (Negligence) and the Economic Efficiency Critique

The primary counterpoint to strict liability is the traditional fault-based system of negligence. Critics, particularly from the Law and Economics movement, argue that strict liability is economically inefficient and unfairly punitive. They contend that imposing liability without proof of fault deters valuable, high-utility activities—such as industrial manufacturing, scientific research, and technological innovation—by imposing unpredictable and excessive financial burdens on businesses. From a corrective justice standpoint, opponents argue that it is morally unjust to hold a defendant liable when they have exercised the utmost reasonable care and taken all possible precautions. Instead, they advocate for a negligence standard, which balances victim compensation with the freedom to innovate, asserting that liability should only arise when there is a demonstrable failure to meet the standard of reasonable care.

Understanding the fundamental definition of a tort, including the distinction between civil civil liability and criminal liability.
The core elements of Negligence (duty, breach, causation, and damages) to contrast with liability-without-fault.
The concepts of legal causation, specifically distinguishing between actual cause (cause-in-fact) and proximate cause.
The standard of care of a 'reasonably prudent person' which serves as the baseline for fault-based torts.
In-depth analysis of Product Liability defects, specifically distinguishing between manufacturing defects, design defects, and warning defects.
Applying the risk-utility test versus the consumer-contemplation test in design defect litigation.
The Economic Loss Rule, which limits recovery under strict liability when a product damages only itself.
Policy rationales behind strict liability, such as enterprise liability, loss-spreading, and deterrence theory.
6.7K views92likes13:33@PassYourBarOriginal Release: 2018-10-03

Strict liability is a legal doctrine that imposes liability without fault, applying only to three major areas: (1) Products liability under Restatement 402A, which requires a defect, seller control, no material alterations, seller in business, causation, and no privity; (2) Abnormally dangerous activities (ultra hazardous activities like fumigation, blasting, or bungee jumping) requiring safety, engagement, risk, and balance of danger versus utility; and (3) Wild animals or domesticated animals with a propensity to do harm. Defenses to strict liability include assumption of risk, failure to follow instructions, and misuse of the product.