Deciphering Linear Elamite Writing: François Desset on Iran's Ancient Script

Added:

Scholarly Skepticism and Provenance Concerns over the Decipherment

While François Desset and his colleagues announced a major breakthrough in deciphering Linear Elamite, their claims have met with significant skepticism from other prominent Near Eastern scholars, such as Jacob Dahl. Critics argue that the corpus of surviving Linear Elamite inscriptions is too small and fragmented to support a complete, reliable decipherment. Furthermore, a substantial portion of the texts used in Desset's study comes from the Mahboubian collection—unprovenanced silver vessels that some epigraphists suspect may be modern forgeries. Because these artifacts lack a secure archaeological context, skeptical scholars argue that the decipherment remains a contested hypothesis rather than an established scientific consensus, emphasizing the need for cautious, independent verification of the linguistic data.

Fundamental concepts of epigraphy and paleography, including the differences between logographic, syllabic, and alphabetic writing systems.
The historical geography of the Ancient Near East, specifically the location of Elam (modern-day Iran) and its relationship with neighboring Mesopotamia.
The basic history of cuneiform writing and its role as the dominant script in the region for millennia.
The linguistic concept of a 'language isolate' and why Elamite does not fit into the Indo-European or Semitic language families.
In-depth analysis of the grammar, phonology, and syntax of the Elamite language as revealed by the newly readable texts.
The ongoing research and decipherment challenges of Proto-Elamite, the older and still largely undeciphered precursor to Linear Elamite.
The historical and geopolitical implications of a literate Bronze Age society in the Iranian Plateau, challenging the Mesopotamia-centric narrative of the invention of writing.
Applying similar decipherment methodologies—such as identifying proper nouns and phonetic values in parallel texts—to other undeciphered scripts like the Indus Valley Script or Linear A.
4.3K views119likes1:44:44@persiapersianOriginal Release: 2022-11-02

Dr François Desset successfully deciphered Linear Elamite, a purely phonetic writing system from the late third millennium BC in southern Iran, which challenges the traditional theory of progressive phonetization of writing systems by demonstrating that pure phonetic writing existed contemporaneously with mixed systems in Mesopotamia and Egypt around 2250 BC.