Evolutionary Psychology of Morality: Lance Workman on Good & Evil

Added:

Cultural Evolutionary Theory and the Adaptationist Critique

Critics of evolutionary psychology, including social constructionists and cultural evolutionary theorists, argue that human morality is not primarily a hardwired product of genetic adaptations. Instead, they propose that moral systems are highly flexible, culturally constructed, and driven by social learning. A major criticism, famously articulated by evolutionary biologists like Stephen Jay Gould, is that evolutionary psychology relies on 'just-so stories'—unverifiable, adaptationist narratives that explain human behavior post hoc without sufficient genetic evidence. Opposing frameworks, such as Dual-Inheritance Theory, emphasize that culture acts as a powerful evolutionary force in its own right. Under this view, human cooperation and moral norms developed rapidly through cultural group selection rather than slowly through genetic changes. Consequently, what evolutionary psychologists perceive as universal, biologically programmed morality is often a reflection of diverse cultural, linguistic, and historical developments.

Basic principles of evolutionary biology, specifically natural selection and the concept of adaptation.
An introductory understanding of evolutionary psychology, which posits that human cognitive processes evolved to solve ancestral survival challenges.
Familiarity with basic social psychology concepts, particularly social identity theory and the dynamics of in-group favoritism and out-group bias.
A foundational grasp of descriptive ethics versus normative ethics to distinguish between how humans actually behave and how they philosophically ought to behave.
Jonathan Haidt's Moral Foundations Theory, to understand the cultural and intuitive variations in human morality.
The application of Game Theory (e.g., the Prisoner's Dilemma) to mathematically model the evolution of cooperation and reciprocal altruism.
Advanced evolutionary theories of psychopathy, specifically examining it as a frequency-dependent behavioral strategy rather than purely a pathology.
The cognitive neuroscience of morality, exploring how brain regions like the prefrontal cortex and amygdala process empathy and moral dilemmas.
4.5K views52likes28:36@Herring1967Original Release: 2017-03-22

Evolutionary psychology explains that human morality evolved from ancestral survival mechanisms, including reciprocal altruism (helping others expecting future reciprocation), ingroup-outgroup bias (favoring one's own group while devaluing others), and natural selection pressures like incest avoidance to prevent genetic disorders; these evolved tendencies create both our capacity for cooperation and our potential for violence, with psychopaths representing an evolutionary adaptation that exploits low-level reciprocation systems, while modern moral dilemmas often conflict with our Stone Age brains adapted for a different environment.