Dr. Erica De Bruin: Preventing Coups d'Etat | Security Studies

Added:

The Provocation Hypothesis and Objective Civilian Control

While counterbalancing is a recognized coup-proofing strategy, critics argue it is a double-edged sword that can actively provoke the coups it aims to prevent. Critics of 'coup-proofing' argue that creating parallel security forces signals deep distrust to the regular military. This erosion of trust, combined with the diversion of resources to loyalist paramilitaries, threatens the institutional prestige and survival of the traditional armed forces, often incentivizing them to launch preemptive coups. Furthermore, classic security theories, such as Samuel Huntington's model of 'objective civilian control,' argue that long-term stability is best achieved not by dividing and weakening the military, but by fostering professionalism, clear boundaries, and political neutrality. From this alternative perspective, counterbalancing severely degrades a nation's military command structure and combat effectiveness. This leaves the state highly vulnerable to external threats and internal insurgencies, ultimately undermining the very regime stability it was designed to protect.

Definition and dynamics of a coup d'état, including how it differs from popular revolutions, civil wars, and riots.
Fundamental concepts of civil-military relations, particularly how civilian leaders attempt to assert control over armed forces.
The concept of the state's monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force (Weberian state theory).
Basic mechanisms of authoritarian regime survival and the internal threats leaders face from their own security apparatus.
The 'Dictator's Dilemma' regarding military effectiveness: how counterbalancing prevents coups but degrades performance in interstate wars.
In-depth analysis of counterbalancing institutions, such as presidential guards, militarized police forces, and parallel intelligence agencies.
Security Sector Reform (SSR) in post-conflict or transitioning states to establish democratic civilian control.
Case studies of coup-proofing strategies in practice, such as in Ba'athist Iraq, Cold War-era Latin America, or modern West Africa.
1K views27likes1:26:28@mitsecuritystudiesprogram5272Original Release: 2022-01-19

Counterbalancing—creating independent security forces outside the regular military chain of command—is an effective coup prevention strategy that reduces the success rate of coup attempts by enabling counterweights to actively resist military coups, though it does not deter coup attempts and may increase the likelihood of coup escalation into civil wars.