Understanding Death's Badness: The Deprivation Account (Philosophy Lecture)

Added:

The Epicurean Challenge and the Symmetry Argument

The primary challenge to the Deprivation Account comes from Epicureanism, specifically the Epicurean "No-Subject" puzzle and Lucretius's Symmetry Argument. Epicurus famously argued that "death is nothing to us," reasoning that for something to be bad for someone, that person must exist to experience the harm. Because a dead person does not exist, there is no subject to suffer the deprivation of life's goods. Expanding on this, the Roman philosopher Lucretius proposed the Symmetry Argument, pointing out that our post-mortem non-existence (the period after we die) is identical to our pre-natal non-existence (the period before we were born). Since we do not view the eternity before our birth as a tragedy or a deprivation of goods, it is irrational to view the eternity after our death as such. Together, these Epicurean arguments challenge the Deprivation Account by questioning how a non-existent entity can be harmed or deprived of anything at all.

Epicurus' challenge to the badness of death (the argument that death cannot harm us because we do not exist to experience it).
Basic theories of well-being (hedonism, desire-satisfaction, and objective list theories) that define what makes a life go well.
The philosophical distinction between intrinsic harm (things bad in themselves) and comparative/extrinsic harm (things bad because of what they prevent).
Thomas Nagel's modern defense of the Deprivation Account and his responses to Epicurean skepticism.
Lucretius' Symmetry Argument, which questions why we fear post-mortem non-existence but not prenatal non-existence.
Bernard Williams' thesis on the 'Tedium of Immortality' and whether an endless life would remain desirable.
The application of the deprivation account to contemporary bioethical issues such as abortion, euthanasia, and life-extension technologies.
72.4K views0likes51:36@YaleCoursesOriginal Release: 2008-09-30

According to the deprivation account, death is bad not because nonexistence is intrinsically bad, but because it deprives us of the good things in life that we would otherwise experience; however, this account faces challenges regarding the timing of death's badness and whether nonexistence can be bad for someone who never existed, leading to the distinction between a bold existence requirement (requiring simultaneous existence with the bad thing) and a modest existence requirement (requiring existence at some time).